Segregated and Commingled IRA Storage
By Kelvin BrattonPublished · Updated
Segregated and commingled storage organize IRA metals differently. Compare holding records, return provisions and charges in the depository agreement.

When you ask for metal back, do you receive the same individual pieces or equivalent products? That's a useful question when comparing segregated and commingled storage. Read the answer in the actual agreement, along with the charges and release process.
Compare the cost of the defined service
Different storage arrangements may have different charges. Request the relevant schedule and understand what it covers. A higher charge should be compared with the actual service provided, not an implication that every other arrangement is unsafe.
Review insurance and access terms as well. An impressive facility description is not a substitute for the contract governing your holding.
Ask what “same metal” means in the agreement
For some products, identification can include a unique bar serial number. For coins without individual serial numbers, identification may focus on type, quantity, issue or packaging under the provider's process. If receiving the original pieces matters, make that requirement explicit and ask how the agreement and inventory system support it.
A commingled physical arrangement can place holdings alongside other clients' holdings while keeping individual holdings records. Whether a distribution returns original pieces or equivalent products depends on the arrangement. Do not assume that “commingled” erases holdings, or that “segregated” automatically provides every legal and insurance protection you could want.
Compare the service procedures alongside the storage method
Review the actual charges, reporting and instruction process. Ask how a discrepancy is investigated, how a sale or distribution is requested and how a change of storage method is handled. The way the metal is physically separated is only one part of those continuing procedures.
In an IRA, product and custody requirements still apply. A preference for particular pieces does not create a right to take them home outside the account's distribution process. Keep the storage decision connected to the account administration rather than treating the depository label as the whole holdings arrangement.
Keep IRA administration in view
If the metal belongs to an IRA, the custodian administers the account instructions and the depository stores the assets. A request to sell and a request for an in-kind distribution are different actions. Your tax professional helps assess the consequences.
LGS explains the purchase and coordinates with your custodian and depository. Choose an arrangement you can describe in terms of records, costs and release—not one you must take on faith.
Further Reading
This article is educational. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell anything, and it does not consider your circumstances. Prices can move in either direction.
